Sections

Court Must Decide If Gavin Grimm’s Case Is Moot

Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook
Subscribe

Don’t miss our updates:

Gavin Grimm, at a 2016 American Civil Liberties Union/ New York Civil Liberties Union event in New York. | DONNA ACETO

In what could signal a disappointing end to a remarkable battle for transgender equality, the Richmond-based Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals has announced that instead of holding oral argument in Gavin Grimm’s lawsuit challenging the Gloucester County, Virginia, School Board’s bathroom access policy, it is sending the case back to the district court to determine whether the young man’s recent graduation from high school makes the case moot.

The three-judge panel had tentatively scheduled an oral argument for September to consider yet again whether District Judge Robert G. Doumar erred when he dismissed Grimm’s Title IX sex discrimination claim, but on August 2 it said more fact-finding by the district court about whether appellate jurisdiction has ended is necessary.

Grimm’s mother filed suit on his behalf against the school board in July 2015, the summer before his junior year, alleging that the board’s policy of requiring students to use restrooms based on their biological sex rather than their gender identity violated Grimm’s right to be free of sex discrimination protected under both Title IX of the Education Amendments Act of 1972 and the Equal Protection Clause of the 14th Amendment.

Fourth Circuit sends trans student bathroom issue back to district judge

In September of that year, Doumar ruled in favor of the school board’s motion to dismiss the Title IX claim, reserved judgment on the 14th Amendment constitutional claim, and denied Grimm’s motion for a preliminary injunction to allow him to use the boys’ bathrooms as he appealed the Title IX dismissal.

While the case was pending before Doumar, the Obama administration filed a joint statement from the Justice and Education Departments supporting Grimm’s claim that barring him from using the boys’ bathrooms violated Title IX, finding that anti-transgender discrimination was necessarily sex discrimination. In April of last year, the Fourth Circuit focused on the federal agencies’ statement and found that Doumar should have deferred to it. In response, Doumar, last June, issued the preliminary injunction Grimm had sought, which would have guaranteed him access to appropriate bathroom facilities during his final year in high school.

Even though both Doumar and the Fourth Circuit refused the school board’s motion that they stay the injunction pending its appeal, the Supreme Court did issue a stay prior to the start of school last fall. The high court was scheduled to take up the school board’s appeal on March 28, but after President Donald Trump took office his attorney general and education secretary, Jeff Sessions and Betsy DeVos, on February 22, withdrew the Obama policy on Title IX’s applicability to transgender students. The Trump administration asserts that the question is best decided at the state and local level, despite the issue being one of federal statutory interpretation.

The Supreme Court reacted to the new Trump administration posture by cancelling the oral argument, vacating the Fourth Circuit’s decision about deferring to a now-defunct federal government policy, and sending the case back to the Fourth Circuit to address the merits of Grimm’s appeal of Doumar’s original ruling.

The Gloucester County School Board now argues the case is moot given that Grimm has graduated. While Grimm asserts his possible “future attendance at alumni and school-community events” there give him a continuing concrete interest in resolving the issue he raised, the board says the question of alumni bathroom access — on which it made no commitment one way or the other — is not before the court.

The matter of a “concrete interest” is critical since courts do not have jurisdiction unless there is an “actual case or controversy” between the parties.

“Thus,” wrote the court, “a crucial threshold question arises in this appeal whether ‘one or both of the parties plainly lack a continuing interest’ in the resolution of this case such that it has become moot.”

Doumar, then, will not be ruling on the merits of the case, but should he conclude it is moot, Grimm could appeal that.

If the district judge instead returns the case to the Fourth Circuit for a ruling on whether the Title IX claim was appropriately dismissed, it may yet provide a vehicle for the American Civil Liberties Union’s LGBT Right Project and the ACLU Foundation of Virginia, which represent Grimm, to get this issue back before the Supreme Court.

This issue is also being litigated in other places, in some cases involving elementary school students, and it is possible that one of the other cases will get far enough along to knock at the Supreme Court’s door long before the plaintiff has graduated. On May 30, the Chicago-based Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals ruled, in Whitaker v. Kenosha (Wisconsin) Unified School District, that Title IX prohibits a public school from refusing to let transgender students use bathrooms appropriate for their gender identity. That is the ruling Grimm and the ACLU would like out of the Fourth Circuit.

The Republican Congress could conceivably intervene by amending Title IX to explicitly exclude transgender students from protection under its sex discrimination provisions — but that is unlikely so long as the Senate filibuster rule remains in place. So it’s likely the issue will one day get to the Supreme Court, with or without Gavin Grimm’s pioneering participation.

Updated 5:17 pm, July 20, 2018
Today’s news:
Share on TwitterTweet
Share on Facebook
Subscribe

Don’t miss our updates:

Reader feedback

sarvc says:
We have seen that to get the musical.ly fans online for the musically app.
Sept. 19, 2017, 12:49 pm
bond550 says:
The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface. PACE Program
Jan. 9, 12:52 am
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readers.Towing in norcross
Jan. 17, 6:02 am
tempmail01 says:
I read that Post and got it fine and informative. Please share more like that... life change reviews
Jan. 23, 1:29 am
thirtysixclub says:
I read that Post and got it fine and informative. Please share more like that...  36c Full Cup Bras
Jan. 28, 4:02 pm
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readers.FuturoCoin
Feb. 1, 4:41 am
jane smith says:
I have never seen before this type of amazing and reliable scheme of Alberta Awards of Excellence in Housing. I’m co-founder of light pink bikinis Firm as well as done Master’s in Property management and I like this offer.
Feb. 1, 12:37 pm
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readers.click here
Feb. 3, 3:43 am
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readers.quotes
Feb. 3, 6:52 am
Sex personal hygiene says:
Really dont know what to say about his personal hygiene
Feb. 7, 4:47 pm
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readers.Purchase drone video footage Morrisey Productions
Feb. 10, 3:54 am
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readersair conditioner energy saver
Feb. 17, 5:51 am
QmmMovers says:
I appreciate everything you have added to my knowledge base.Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer.Thanks. Roofing Aurora
Feb. 18, 3:32 am
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readersPS4 Home
Feb. 18, 4:43 am
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readersPS4 Home
Feb. 18, 4:43 am
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readersClickHowTo.com
Feb. 18, 9:01 am
jakiejack6 says:
I am continually amazed by the amount of information available on this subject. What you presented was well researched and well worded in order to get your stand on this across to all your readersInvokana amputation Lawsuit
Feb. 19, 2:41 am
bond550 says:
Excellent and very exciting site. Love to watch. Keep Rocking. dentist near me
March 3, 5:43 pm
bond550 says:
Excellent and very exciting site. Love to watch. Keep Rocking. dentist near me
March 3, 5:43 pm
Naturopaths says:
Because of this , it truly is superior you can applicable research prior to providing. It will be possible to share larger document that way.largest business directory
March 23, 4:12 pm
wpplugins4 says:
Great post. you have pointed out some excellent points. I as well believe this is a very superb website. Karnataka Legislative Assembly Election Polling Results 2018
April 7, 5:07 pm
simonascare9 says:
I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. Thank you for the post. spark energy
April 16, 4:57 am
watchrugbyliveweb says:
I found your this post while searching for some related information on blog search...Its a good post..keep posting and update the information. FLC Star Tower
April 21, 8:17 am
QmmMovers says:
I appreciate everything you have added to my knowledge base.Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer.Thanks. Roofing Aurora
April 21, 8:31 am
QmmMovers says:
I appreciate everything you have added to my knowledge base.Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer.Thanks. Roofing Aurora
April 21, 8:31 am
QmmMovers says:
I appreciate everything you have added to my knowledge base.Admiring the time and effort you put into your blog and detailed information you offer.Thanks. Roofing Aurora
April 21, 8:31 am
QmmMovers says:
You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant! Reselling sneakers
April 21, 9:20 am
QmmMovers says:
You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant! Reselling sneakers
April 21, 9:21 am
QmmMovers says:
You know your projects stand out of the herd. There is something special about them. It seems to me all of them are really brilliant! Reselling sneakers
April 21, 9:21 am
watchrugbyliveweb says:
I found your this post while searching for some related information on blog search...Its a good post..keep posting and update the information. WebsiteHosting.com
April 22, 4:53 am
Garden Dental says:
Absolutely posting! Lots of useful information and inspiration, both of which we all need!Relay appreciate your work. Dentist in Spruce Grove best Dentist Spruce Grove
April 27, 10:09 am
renaultwreckers says:
The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface. Train de vie artificiel par le crédit
May 1, 6:19 am
oakville dentist says:
Thank you for helping people get the information they need. Great stuff as usual. Keep up the great work!!! Dentist in Oakville Oakville Dentist
May 9, 9:02 am
purified111 says:
You completed a few fine points there. I did a search on the subject and found nearly all persons will go along with with your blog. Webdesign
May 9, 9:14 am
purified111 says:
You completed a few fine points there. I did a search on the subject and found nearly all persons will go along with with your blog. Webdesign
May 10, 8:08 am
purified111 says:
Good website! I truly love how it is easy on my eyes it is. I am wondering how I might be notified whenever a new post has been made. I have subscribed to your RSS which may do the trick? Have a great day! Inc profile
May 12, 11:48 am
sierraspringsdental says:
Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking. Airdrie Dentist Dentist Airdrie Dentist in Airdrie dentist near me Airdrie
May 17, 4:11 pm
sierraspringsdental says:
Great article Lot's of information to Read... Great Man Keep Posting and update to People..Thanks Airdrie Dentist Dentist Airdrie Dentist in Airdrie dentist near me Airdrie
May 17, 4:59 pm
jamsmalik says:
That is really nice to hear. thank you for the update and good luck. comprar por internet
May 20, 5:47 pm
smilezoneedmonton says:
Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking. Edmonton Dentist near me Edmonton Dentist Dentist in Edmonton
May 21, 1:27 pm
smilezoneedmonton says:
Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking. Edmonton Dentist near me Edmonton Dentist Dentist in Edmonton
May 21, 2:23 pm
jamsmalik says:
That is really nice to hear. thank you for the update and good luck. Where can i buy glass pipes online
June 9, 9:51 pm
jamsmalik says:
That is really nice to hear. thank you for the update and good luck. romani in londra chirii
June 25, 9:04 am
jamsmalik says:
Thanks for your post. I’ve been thinking about writing a very comparable post over the last couple of weeks. I’ll probably keep it short and sweet and link to this instead if thats cool. Thanks. construction cost
June 27, 9:34 am

Comments closed.

Classifieds

Schneps Community News Group

Don’t miss out!

Stay in touch with your community. Subscribe to our free newsletter:

Optional: